Wednesday, September 2, 2009
Uncommon Dissent edited by William Dembski
This is a good collection of essays by Darwin skeptics. It is a good resource. The most surprising essay is by Michael Denton, who perhaps started a wing of Darwin Doubting with "Evolution: A Theory in Crisis" but now has changed his view into an interest in self-organization as an inherent property of matter, which is perhaps just another form of materialism which most of the other authors reject. The interview of Schutzenberger is very interesting. Budziszewski is brilliant and gives real philosophical weight to the discussion. Tipler is interesting on peer review holding back scientific progress. Some of the writers seem to anticipate more recent findings of lateral gene transfer and regulatory parts of the genome, which create great problems for the "tree of life." Soon another collection of these and other authors will be needed.
Probability's Nature and Nature's Probability by Donald E. Johnson
This is a probabilistic refutation of Neo-Darwinism on informational and mathematical grounds. It is full of interesting quotes. The format is barely readable and the quotes, though carefully referenced, could be closely edited for effect. However, I myself think they are representative. An evolutionist can say "appearance of design" dismissively only so often without having to try to quantify "possible" and "given enough time" etc. An evolutionist can invoke comets, panspermia, anything but intelligence, and not be ostracized. Yet intelligence is our only empirically tested source of true (as opposed to Shannon) information. Useful also for bibliography.
A Corpse in the Koryo by James Church
(read aloud over dishes) Seems to be a murder mystery with a dead body and an inspector, but turns out to be about survival in North Korea, where behind each intrigue is more intrigue and one branch of government is watching another. The two main characters are portrayed so well that the reader becomes very attached. This leads to humor and fear and some sadness. The ending is predictable and seems right but is a little disappointing. Closing the book one feels real regret not having more time with "Inspector O."
The Associate by John Grisham
Read during dishes, fun to read, good plot, but ending a little unfulfilling. The usual bad lawyers and good lawyers in a shadowy world.
Creation as Science by Hugh Ross
This book is good about framing the debate, and I think he does understand science. His biblical interpretation is to me not accurate, attributing far too much precision to texts that are just descriptive. And like many, he misunderstands intelligent design arguments. His testable model to me is arcane.
Flotsametrics and the Floating World: How one man's obsession with runaway sneakers and rubber ducks revolutionized ocean science by Curtis Ebbesmeyer
This is a wonderful book about everything that floats in the ocean and why it goes where it does and how fast. There are circular currents, beaches that collect debris, and large areas of ocean choked with plastic. By tracking ordinary flotsam, Ebbesmeyer has made the ocean currents give up many of their secrets. He weaves history, science, and beachcombing into a fascinating tale. He writes with the confident but understated tone of someone who really knows what he is writing about.
Supercontinent by Ted Nield
The earth's crust is floating on the mantle of the earth and moving to make supercontinents and fracturing to make oceans and colliding to make mountains. The story of proving this is amazing. The reluctance of the scientific community to embrace this idea is alluded to in the book and is a cautionary tale to those who worship science.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)