Wednesday, April 23, 2008

Ever Since Darwin by Stephen Jay Gould

A series of essays, useful because Gould, who seemingly has impeccable evolutionary credentials, seems to see a myriad of problems with standard evolutionary models. He seems to be looking for a way out without leaving the "reservation." His defense of evolution is spirited but unconvincing. His criticism of parts of standard theory is surprisingly pointed. While disagreeing with other non-evolutionary views he is patient and respectful. His view of the scientific enterprise and its own dogma is disarmingly frank and trenchant. I am sure many in the evolutionary camp are not mourning his passing. Myself, after reading this, will miss him.

No comments: